The decade of the 1880s' brought greater exploitation of Wisconsin's north woods and with that came an increased population. With the construction of the railroads, villages were settled though out the northern wilderness. One such hamlet was Tigerton which was established along the banks of the south branch of the Embarrass River just southeast of Wittenberg in Shawano County. Partners Livingstone and Newbold built the first saw mill in Tigerton, and Mr. Livingstone opened the first grocery store, while Mr. Newbold built a hotel. There is a notice for sealed bids in the Oshkosh Daily Northwestern of May 12, 1881 and seven day later in the Oshkosh Weekly Northwestern, an article which mentions the Newbold boarding house to be built in Tigerton. The description was simply; " ...frame, two stories high, 40 x 60, $4,000".
Of the next building I'm unsure, it may or may not have been designed by William Waters. In the Oshkosh Daily Northwestern of April 11, 1887, under the heading SHORT NOTES. was this little tidbit, ... Fred Viall and C. D. Rose will be proprietors of a new hotel to be built at Antigo. The building will cost between $8,000 and $10,000. Wm. Waters will draw the plans for the new hotel... Fred Viall was a grocer and Charles Rose was the editor of The Wisconsin Telegraph and both were listed in the Oshkosh City Directory of 1886, after that year Mr. Vialls' name no longer appeared in the city directories. There was just one hotel built in Antigo that year and it was named the Vivian Hotel. The hotel was finished in October of 1887 and the names listed as the money behind the enterprise were E. N. Miller, W.W. Hutchinson and A. W. Larson, none of whom had any connection with Oshkosh. Nowhere was there any mention of Fred Viall.
It is difficult to judge if William Waters was the architect of this building, as the one photograph I could find was rather murky. There didn't seem to be many of the hallmark details used by Waters at that time. More research is called for but I'm doubtful that the building razed 2007 was designed by architect Waters. Perhaps the deal with Rose and Viall fell though but the notion was pursued by others.