I can trace my interest in architect Waters to some old acquaintances: Lee and Eileen Weigert. I had known them since I was in first grade, the parents of a classmate and friend. The Weigerts were devotees of Oshkosh history and William Waters. In 1977 I entered the Oshkosh Public Museum Art Fair, one of my drawings was a pen and ink called “Glimpses of Oshkosh, Wisconsin” and featured drawings of many prominent Oshkosh buildings. The Wiegerts and I were talking when Lee said, “You know Richard, all these buildings were designed by William Waters. Do you know much about him?” I had to plead ignorance and the Wiegerts filled me in on Mr. Waters. Eileen told me of a house on Waugoo Avenue as being a Waters job but remodeled beyond recognition. She described in detail its location and I at once knew of which house she spoke, it was number 316 Waugoo or old number 91.
Numbers 2, 3 are address 91, 101
Until recently I never pursued much research on architect Waters’ early works. The collection of sketches compiled by William Waters Jr. as a boy had been a great help in discerning works from the 1870’s and photographic evidence showed architectural details also seen in the sketches of “Willie’s Book”. I was now able to identify some Mr. Waters’ early residential works and I concluded that the houses at 91 and 101 Waugoo Avenue were both the work of architect Waters, but to linking the house to the person who had it built was another matter. The Oshkosh city directories from the 1870’s list names, occupations and home address, there was no listing of street addresses and occupant name.
In 1891, D. C. Buckstaff resided at number 91 Waugoo, he was the treasurer of the Buckstaff and Edwards Company. D. C. Buckstaff isn’t listed in the 1879 directory and all other Buckstaffs are listed as living on the south-side and working for Buckstaff Brother and Chase Company. The occupant of number 101 Waugoo in 1891 was Herman Derksen, a cigar maker who had previously lived at number 152 Main Street. It was unlikely that either man had these homes built for them.
Both building have long since been demolished but it's nice to imagine the days when the street was lined with houses, not parking lots.